The independent directors of Coal India Ltd (CIL) have suggested the Coal Ministry and CIL that the recent proposal of Central Electricity Authority (CEA) regarding the import of coal would benefit only the Independent Power Producers (IPPs) at the expenses of public money.
The independent directors have sent a note to CIL as well as Coal Ministry wherein the have asked the official directors to re-consider their stand in view of the grave legal, commercial, economic and ethical problems arising out of their supporting the CEA views.
The proposal of CEA was as below:
- CIL shall import around 20 million tonnes of coal in 2012-13 and supply the same at a subsidised price (nearly half of the cost price) to IPPs.
- This will result in a loss of Rs. 3,000 Crore annually to the company and over 20 years the same will be around Rs. 60,000 Crore.
- The above losses shall be made good by increasing the prices of indigenous coal to about Rs.100 a tonne for all power producers.
- The decisions of CIL in finalising the terms of the fuel supply agreements (FSAs), including the trigger point at 80 per cent of annual contracted quantity (ACQ) and the rate of penalty at 0.01 per cent taken on April 16, were a result of wide and deep deliberations carried out at several meetings of the CIL board this year in pursuance of the April 4 Presidential directive.
- These decisions have already been implemented in the case of 29 private power producers.
- It states that no arrangement has been made by the CIL management to protect the company or its directors against allegations and proceedings likely to come up by deviating from the Presidential directive. The note states that the new dispensations entail lowering the trigger points from 80 per cent of ACQ to 65 per cent but also seek to levy penalty ranging from 5 to 40 per cent of the quantity not delivered. This mechanism is sought to be justified on the ground of ensuring better performance of CIL.
- The management seems to agree with the premise that the qualitative changes for securing productivity can be obtained only by a threat of penalty of 40 per cent. To us, it looks like an arrangement to transfer thousands of crores of public money to the private power producers in the name of penalty over CIL.
More news on this topic:
http://www.thehindu.com/business/coal-india-board-split-on-cea-proposals/article3958525.ece
No comments:
Post a Comment